Date of composition: 1795
Premiere: 4 May 1795 at the King’s Theatre, London, conducted by the composer
Duration: 29 minutes
Performances by the Berliner Philharmoniker:
First performed on 19 March 1886, conductor: Karl Klindworth
When Prince Nikolaus Esterházy died in 1790, a new chapter began in Haydn’s life. His long-time employer’s successor disbanded the court orchestra – though fortunately not without providing the Kapellmeister with a generous pension. Secure in this way, Haydn was able to turn down flattering offers from the courts of Naples and Pressburg and throw himself instead into London’s vibrant public concert life. Engaged by the concert promoter Johann Peter Salomon, he initially contributed six symphonies (Nos. 93–98) to Salomon’s subscription concerts. Their success was sensational, and so, in early 1794, the composer travelled to England once more, staying for a further year and a half. There he performed three more symphonies (Nos. 99–101) at the Salomon concerts, and a further three (Nos. 102–104) at violinist Giovanni Battista Viotti’s “Opera Concerts”. The Symphony No. 104 in D major therefore bears the sobriquet “Salomon” quite wrongly. Of the performance, Haydn noted in his diary (now sadly lost): “On 4 May 1795 I gave my benefit concert at the Haymarket Theatre. … The whole company was extremely pleased, and so was I. I made four thousand guilders that evening. Such a thing is only possible in England.”
“Such a thing is only possible in England” – these words apply just as well to the music itself, which was shaped by the conditions of performance in London. Here Haydn had an orchestra of sixty musicians at his disposal – more than twice as many as had ever been employed at Esterháza Palace. The writing in his last symphonies is consequently broader in scale and more orchestral in character. Haydn also found in London a wide and very mixed audience: connoisseurs and amateurs, genuine music lovers and nouveaux riches who merely wanted to be seen. He therefore had to offer popular melodies and striking sound effects, while also weaving them into artful, coherent movement structures. The music needed to be easy to grasp, yet sufficiently complex.
Symphony No. 104 shows impressively how economically Haydn handled his material: where one would expect a second theme in the exposition of the opening movement, the main theme returns instead, this time shifted merely to the fifth degree, the dominant. The second movement takes this principle of monothematicism even further: it is built on a single motif, developed, embellished, varied and transposed into other keys with inexhaustible imagination. The minuet offers fine examples of Haydn’s musical humour: first, the triple metre briefly turns into a duple one; then a great timpani crescendo creates entirely inappropriate drama; and finally, a continuation of the opening theme simply breaks off just before the expected trill. After a two-bar general pause, the trill is delivered after all – quietly, but twice as long. As so often, the finale is designed for audience appeal. Haydn is said to have drawn on an old Croatian folk song for it; at the very least, its compositional technique has markedly folk-like traits: the melody unfolds over a sustained bass note, of the kind heard on a bagpipe or hurdy-gurdy. This effect earned Haydn’s final symphony two further sobriquets – the “Bagpipe” or “Bear Dance” Symphony.